I think we should have a strict elemental chart similar to pokemon or other games, that way we can see who does more damage on what. Because I see some crazy people saying stuff like wind magic does 20% more on lightning like where'd u get that from?
Elemental Charts
Miharu
- 
Lineage : Musashi's Descent
Position : None
Posts : 71
Guild : Fairy Tail
Cosmic Coins : 0
Dungeon Tokens : 0
Age : 28
Experience : 25
Character Sheet
First Skill: Earth Dragon Slayer Magic
Second Skill:
Third Skill:
Felicity Vrago
- 
- 
- 
- 
-
Lineage : Angel of Chaos
Position : None
Posts : 1155
Guild : Eclipse Soul
Cosmic Coins : 0
Dungeon Tokens : 0
Age : 37
Mentor : Conquest/Decayuss
Experience : 56875
Character Sheet
First Skill: Crimson God Slayer
Second Skill: Conquest Take Over
Third Skill:
Yes and no. They cannot deal extra damage to the USER, but the Magic itself they deal extra damage. Humans are still flesh and bone despite the awesome magic at their fingertips. You get a mod or admin if they try that on you.
It even doesn't matter if you are a Slayer, still flesh and bones.
Elemental charts are also subjective, but some kind of order in this game of rock, paper, scissors would be nice.
It even doesn't matter if you are a Slayer, still flesh and bones.
Elemental charts are also subjective, but some kind of order in this game of rock, paper, scissors would be nice.
Chaotic RumbleDark Insanity
- 
- 
- 
- - - 
- 
- 
- - 
- 
- 
- 
- - - 
- 
- 
- 
- 
- 
- 
- 
- 
- 
- 
- ![Grand Master [2000]](https://i.imgur.com/SGD5XSW.png)
- ![Master [1000]](https://i.imgur.com/AQXM4xC.png)
- ![Senior [500]](https://i.imgur.com/Nmfn8cD.png)
- ![Novice [250]](https://i.imgur.com/lrYlde6.png)
- 
- -
Lineage : Corrupted King of Knights
Position : King Of Kings
Posts : 2754
Guild : Blue Pegasus
Cosmic Coins : 0
Dungeon Tokens : 0
Age : 26
Mentor : Sapphiron ; The Shadow
Experience : 601,187
Character Sheet
First Skill: Refraction : Sword King
Second Skill: N/A (for now)
Third Skill:
Don't agree with this. Every magic is different in its own way; this removes creativity, essentially, since now it'd be forcing something upon the users, which really isn't required. Let them do whatever they want; if a fire magic is supposed to be stronger than water magic, so be it. The members are responsible for whatever elemental weaknesses they have. Something that I can possibly see, however, is to give every elemental magic an elemental weakness -minimum-. I can see that working far better.
Haru-senpai- -
- - - - - 
- - - 
- - - - - 
- 
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 
- 
- -
Lineage : Monkey King's Descendant
Position : None
Posts : 3216
Guild : Fairy Tail
Cosmic Coins : 0
Dungeon Tokens : 12
Mentor : Igneel, & Noheme the Fox
Experience : 11,106.25
Character Sheet
First Skill: Fire Dragon Slayer Magic
Second Skill: Dragon Force
Third Skill:
Don't agree with this either; I agree with Chaotic. Magic and Weaknesses should be left completely up to the creator.
Here's Why. I will give you Heero's complete chart.
Heero
---------------
Each persons magic has different Strengths, and Weaknesses, and is Very, Very unique. You can ENCOURAGE them, as a Mod. To have a Weakness to Fire if they use Plant or Wood Magic. You may even INSIST, upon it at times if it's straight up Elemental Magic.
But for the most part; every Magic is different.
I mean, my Dragon Slayer Lightning has VERY different strengths and Weaknesses than some other Lightning Magic and also has MANY similarities, naturally as they are the same element.
But that is where the fun lies, and as Chaotic said we should leave it as is
As far as Luke's Example Goes. It's all about Rank. Gray was able to freeze that Fire because his Ice was higher Rank. Same goes with the Boiling Water scenario.
Here's an Example
-------------------------
You light a Lighter or a Candle in your Hand.
You blow it out.
It goes out Easily because the Wind is Higher Ranked than the Fire.
You light a campfire / bonfire.
You blow in it.
It gets larger and is fueled the more you try to blow at it or fan at it.
Because the Fire is Higher Ranked than the Wind.
Here's Why. I will give you Heero's complete chart.
Heero
---------------
- Spoiler:
Dragon Slayer Lightning Weak v.
-----------------------------------------
Wind Element (If Equal Rank Carries and Redirects the Lightning)
Fire Element (If Equal Rank Explodes on Contact)
Metal Element (Homes in No matter What 100% accuracy, Can be Used to Redirect Heero's Magic)
Dragon Slayer Lightning Strong v.
-------------------------------------------
Plant Element (Destroys anything Equal or Lower Ranked on Contact)
Wood Element (Shatters anything Equal or Lower Ranked on Contact)
Water Element (Zips up and Electrocutes the Enemy Caster, Deals Double Damage to Anyone Using Water Magic, Standing in Water, or Soaked)
Metal Element (Homes in No matter What 100% accuracy)
ALTHOUGH, the wind Weakness has been sort of negated by me being a Sky Dragon as well now, you get the picture.
Each persons magic has different Strengths, and Weaknesses, and is Very, Very unique. You can ENCOURAGE them, as a Mod. To have a Weakness to Fire if they use Plant or Wood Magic. You may even INSIST, upon it at times if it's straight up Elemental Magic.
But for the most part; every Magic is different.
I mean, my Dragon Slayer Lightning has VERY different strengths and Weaknesses than some other Lightning Magic and also has MANY similarities, naturally as they are the same element.
But that is where the fun lies, and as Chaotic said we should leave it as is
As far as Luke's Example Goes. It's all about Rank. Gray was able to freeze that Fire because his Ice was higher Rank. Same goes with the Boiling Water scenario.
Here's an Example
-------------------------
You light a Lighter or a Candle in your Hand.
You blow it out.
It goes out Easily because the Wind is Higher Ranked than the Fire.
You light a campfire / bonfire.
You blow in it.
It gets larger and is fueled the more you try to blow at it or fan at it.
Because the Fire is Higher Ranked than the Wind.
Miharu- -
Lineage : Musashi's Descent
Position : None
Posts : 71
Guild : Fairy Tail
Cosmic Coins : 0
Dungeon Tokens : 0
Age : 28
Experience : 25
Character Sheet
First Skill: Earth Dragon Slayer Magic
Second Skill:
Third Skill:
Sorry, I understand. It was just an idea, I realize combat is up to the creators, but I just wanted some system to keep certain things as a system. People say we have stats coming, but I for now I just see 20% here and there, 25% here and there.
Kusanagi- -
Lineage : None
Position : None
Posts : 256
Cosmic Coins : 0
Dungeon Tokens : 0
Experience : 37.5
It's basically what katherine said. If a water attack and fire attack collide, naturally the water attack defeats the fire attack but that doesn't mean it does more damage to you unless you specify that as a weakness(like really specify like what I did with Hiro and holy/light magic)
E's Dialogue
E's Thoughts
DaikoVenom Demon
- - 
- - - - - - - - - - - - 
-
Lineage : Son of Creation
Position : None
Posts : 610
Guild : Fairy Tail
Cosmic Coins : 0
Dungeon Tokens : 0
Age : 27
Mentor : Himself
Experience : 2050
Character Sheet
First Skill: Not being banned yet
Second Skill:
Third Skill:
If you take a look at the rules, it states that overpowering spells is by their power. [ toolazytoaddlink ], so fire could overpower fire, if conditions are met. It's a different case with some elements, such as.. my Smoke. My smoke is weak to wind, because that's one of the drawbacks. If I hadn't written that, it would be the same as wind facing wind, or wind facing anything else.
-nodnod-
-nodnod-
"Oh, Guest... If only you knew..."
Jobs
[ D-Rank - 6 || C-Rank - 2 || B-Rank - 1 || A-Rank - 0 || S-Rank - 0 ]
[ 2050 / 7500 EXP ]
- Other Signitures:
- Dai Fans Only:
Miharu- -
Lineage : Musashi's Descent
Position : None
Posts : 71
Guild : Fairy Tail
Cosmic Coins : 0
Dungeon Tokens : 0
Age : 28
Experience : 25
Character Sheet
First Skill: Earth Dragon Slayer Magic
Second Skill:
Third Skill:
ah I see excuse my ignorance
DaikoVenom Demon
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Lineage : Son of Creation
Position : None
Posts : 610
Guild : Fairy Tail
Cosmic Coins : 0
Dungeon Tokens : 0
Age : 27
Mentor : Himself
Experience : 2050
Character Sheet
First Skill: Not being banned yet
Second Skill:
Third Skill:
No, it's not ignorance; the suggestions are here so you can suggest stuff xD
"Oh, Guest... If only you knew..."
Jobs
[ D-Rank - 6 || C-Rank - 2 || B-Rank - 1 || A-Rank - 0 || S-Rank - 0 ]
[ 2050 / 7500 EXP ]
- Other Signitures:
- Dai Fans Only:
Aria BelerenCosmic Soul
- - - - - - - -
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - 
- - 
- -
Position : None
Posts : 1840
Dungeon Tokens : 0
Age : 36
Mentor : Memnarch
Experience : 0
Character Sheet
First Skill: Tergiversation Arts
Second Skill:
Third Skill:
Daiko wrote:No, it's not ignorance; the suggestions are here so you can suggest stuff xD
No such thing as a stupid question
- Themes:
- Character Track:
- Character Track 2:
- Battle Music (Angry):
- Battle Music (General):
AkeyaTwilight Dragon
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Lineage : Hic Sunt Dracones
Position : None
Faction : The Luminous Covenant
Posts : 1385
Guild : Fairy Tail (Ace)
Cosmic Coins : 0
Dungeon Tokens : 0
Mentor : Whedalsin
Experience : 1,269,023
Character Sheet
First Skill: Twilight Dragon Magic
Second Skill: Twilight Dragon Magic
Third Skill: Twilight Dragon Magic
Agree with others that it's better to not put restrictions on what elemental magic has to be weak to what elemental magic.
It's of course expected that some stuff beats others but it shouldn't be written in stone and some people can think of some very crazy but interesting ideas on how their weaknesses are extremely different from what their magic would usually have.
Also, the lightning vs wind thing is probably because air is actually a terrible conductor so you can easily block lightning with it unless the lightning is just that much stronger.
It's of course expected that some stuff beats others but it shouldn't be written in stone and some people can think of some very crazy but interesting ideas on how their weaknesses are extremely different from what their magic would usually have.
Also, the lightning vs wind thing is probably because air is actually a terrible conductor so you can easily block lightning with it unless the lightning is just that much stronger.
